Missouri Secretary of State Hoskins directed officials to use congressional map barred by state Supreme Court injunction
On September 8, 2026, Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins emailed local election officials instructing them to use the 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map, attaching a same-day federal district court order he said "takes precedence" over the Missouri Supreme Court's standing injunction barring him from using that map. The Missouri Supreme Court responded by opening a contempt inquiry, ordering Hoskins to appear in person and explain why he should not be held in contempt at a hearing set for September 10.
Actors
On September 8, 2026, Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins emailed local election officials directing them to use the state's 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map for the November general election, attaching a copy of a same-day order from Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark of the Eastern District of Missouri. Hoskins told officials Clark's order "takes precedence over the Missouri Supreme Court's order" — the Missouri Supreme Court's own September 3 ruling, which had permanently enjoined Hoskins from implementing or using the 2025 map after finding the map had never legally taken effect and ordering Missouri to revert to the map used in 2022 and 2024.
Hoskins's email came hours after a flurry of court activity: U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh rejected Missouri Republican officials' emergency application to stay the state court's order, after which Judge Clark — acting in a separate federal lawsuit filed by U.S. Rep. Bob Onder, state Sen. Rick Brattin and two voters seeking to keep the 2025 map in place — issued his own temporary restraining order requiring the state to use that map instead, producing dueling state and federal directives. Attorney General Catherine Hanaway said the state would comply with Clark's order.
People Not Politicians, the PAC that had forced the referendum blocking the 2025 map, filed a contempt motion the same night through attorney Chuck Hatfield, arguing that regardless of the federal order, "the Missouri Secretary of State must comply with this court's injunction" and that Hoskins's email directed election officials to use a map the state's highest court had expressly barred him from implementing. Missouri Supreme Court Chief Justice W. Brent Powell ordered Hoskins to answer in writing by noon September 9 and to appear in person at a contempt hearing set for 10 a.m. September 10, asking Hoskins to explain why his email was not an affirmative violation of the court's injunction.
Why we recorded this
A state supreme court's injunction is not optional once issued, and the official it binds does not get to pick a different court's order instead because he prefers its outcome. Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins was permanently enjoined from using the state's 2025 congressional map; when a federal judge issued a same-day order that Hoskins read more favorably, he told local election officials to use the map the state's highest court had just barred him from using. This archive records the defiance itself, distinct from the underlying map fight, because an official choosing which binding order to obey is the rule of law breaking down at the point where it is supposed to be automatic.
Sources
- Missouri Supreme Court orders Denny Hoskins to answer on contempt charge — KBIA / NPR Missouri primary accessed September 9, 2026
- Missouri court opens contempt probe into Republican official over redistricting fight — NBC News investigative accessed September 9, 2026
See also
- Trump administration defies court order to resume immigration processing for 39 countries
- ICE deports Adelanto hunger-strike organizer Kyon Swaso to Belize after no-notice out-of-state transfers
- DOJ refused judge's order to confirm termination of $1.8B 'anti-weaponization fund'
- Court monitor report finds Maricopa County Sheriff's Office undermined racial-profiling settlement, retaliated against reform commander
- ICE arrested two immigrants at New York City immigration courts in defiance of federal court orders, including a June 23 nationwide ban
Receive the daily digest by email
One email each morning with every entry filed the day before. Free. No tracking, no ads. Unsubscribe anytime.
