ICE detained a longtime Beaverton, Oregon resident under a misapplied mandatory-detention law after a random license-plate dragnet flagged him
On November 8, 2025, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained J.Y.L.C., a 24-year-old Guatemalan man who had lived in Oregon since 2017 and had a pending asylum case, after randomly running his vehicle's license plate and citing an address-update lapse as grounds to treat him as a flight risk. ICE held him under a statute mandating detention for immigrants newly arriving at the border, a provision U.S. District Judge Amy Baggio ruled did not apply to someone who had lived in the country for eight years, and ordered ICE to provide a bond hearing or release him.
Actors
On November 8, 2025, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers in Beaverton, Oregon ran the license plate of a vehicle as part of a program the agency described in court filings as randomly checking vehicle plates and the names and birthdates of registered owners against DHS databases to identify people unlawfully present, without targeting any particular vehicle or driver [1]. The check identified the driver, J.Y.L.C., a 24-year-old Guatemalan man who has lived in Oregon since 2017 and filed for asylum in 2019, with a hearing scheduled for the following month [1]. Officers pulled him over, cited an address discrepancy in his vehicle registration as grounds that he was a "flight risk," and generated an arrest warrant on the spot; he was detained under Immigration and Nationality Act Section 235(b)(2)(A), a provision requiring mandatory detention for immigrants newly arriving at the border pending removal [1].
U.S. District Judge Amy Baggio ruled that Section 235(b)(2)(A) does not apply to someone who has lived in the country for eight years, found the detention unlawful, and ordered ICE to give J.Y.L.C. a bond hearing within days or release him [1]. The bond hearing was held and bail was set, but because it concluded after ICE's Tacoma facility had closed for the day, J.Y.L.C.'s family could not post bond until the facility reopened the following business day [1]. His attorney, Nicholas Costa, said he had nine minutes to file an emergency habeas petition and restraining-order request before ICE transferred J.Y.L.C. out of Oregon — a window that, had he missed it, would have left the court without jurisdiction to intervene [1].
Why we recorded this
Due process requires that mandatory pretrial detention be reserved for the narrow category of immigrants the underlying statute actually covers, not applied by default whenever an enforcement stop turns something up. A federal judge found that ICE detained a man who had lived in Oregon for eight years under a provision written for people newly arriving at the border, after a program that randomly runs vehicle plates to check immigration status flagged him. This archive records the case because a statute's reach was stretched far past what it authorizes, and it took a court, not the agency's own judgment, to correct it.
Sources
- Federal judge finds ICE's license plate checks led to unlawful arrest in Beaverton case — KATU primary accessed September 10, 2026
See also
- ICE deported Oceanside father of a U.S. Marine without notice or a hearing, despite his deferred-action protection
- ICE agents arrested Victor Cruz Gamez without a warrant in Hillsboro, Oregon, and held him more than three weeks despite his valid work permit
- ICE arrested a misidentified Durango asylum-seeker and his two children without a warrant en route to school
- ICE detained and deported Babson College freshman despite no valid removal order; judge ordered her return
- ICE detained visa holder in unheated, overcrowded Central Islip courthouse cell for days without beds or showers
Receive the daily digest by email
One email each morning with every entry filed the day before. Free. No tracking, no ads. Unsubscribe anytime.
