U.S. Department of Justice fired prosecutor who withdrew from dismissed Adani bribery case rather than sign the dismissal motion

The U.S. Department of Justice fired Andrew Tyler, an acting assistant chief in the Criminal Division's Fraud Section, on September 8, 2026, over unspecified "allegations of ethical violations." Tyler had withdrawn from the department's foreign-bribery and securities-fraud case against Indian billionaire Gautam Adani months earlier rather than sign DOJ's motion to dismiss the charges -- a dismissal U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis said senior official Trent McCotter pursued in a "highly unusual" manner without input from the prosecutors who built the case. DOJ gave no reason connecting the firing to Tyler's withdrawal, but reporting frames it as the second firing this month of a career prosecutor who resisted a politically directed decision in a high-profile case.

On September 8, 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice fired Andrew Tyler, an acting assistant chief in the Criminal Division's Fraud Section, over unspecified "allegations of ethical violations," according to multiple people familiar with the matter. Tyler could not immediately be reached for comment; a person who had previously worked with him described him as a dedicated career employee.

Tyler and a co-counsel, Shy Jackson, had withdrawn from the department's prosecution of Indian billionaire Gautam Adani and several co-defendants in a foreign-bribery and securities-fraud case -- an act reporting described as a quiet form of protest -- after senior officials moved in May 2026 to dismiss the charges. The dismissal motion was signed only by politically appointed Justice Department officials, not by the career prosecutors who had handled the case. U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis of the Eastern District of New York initially declined to dismiss the case, saying DOJ had not provided an adequate factual basis, and later said acting deputy attorney general Trent McCotter, who ordered the dismissal, had "eschewed the professional opinions of innumerable officials from various federal offices and replaced them with his singular judgment." Garaufis went on to dismiss the charges against Adani and several co-defendants but refused to drop the remaining counts against others, citing DOJ's failure to provide new reasons or facts for doing so.

Reporting describes Tyler's firing as the second this month of a career federal prosecutor who clashed with senior department officials over a high-profile case, following the firing of a Minneapolis-based prosecutor earlier in September over his handling of a civil-rights investigation into an ICE shooting.

A functioning Justice Department depends on career prosecutors being free to decline participation in a decision they believe is improper without losing their job for it. DOJ fired Andrew Tyler, an acting assistant chief in the Criminal Division's Fraud Section, days after he and a co-counsel withdrew from the prosecution of Gautam Adani rather than sign the motion dismissing the case -- a dismissal a federal judge had already faulted DOJ leadership for pursuing without input from the prosecutors who built it. This archive records the firing because removing a prosecutor for declining to carry out a politically directed charging decision converts personnel authority into a tool for enforcing compliance rather than professional legal judgment.

  1. Federal prosecutor who withdrew from dismissed bribery case against Indian billionaire Adani fired, sources say — CBS News investigative accessed September 10, 2026
  2. Trump administration fires prosecutor in dropped case against politically-linked Indian billionaire — NBC News investigative accessed September 10, 2026
  3. Prosecutor who withdrew from dismissed Adani bribery case fired, sources say — CBS News (via ForeverDelmarva syndication) investigative accessed September 10, 2026